The Hangout

Ask questions; help others; share stories.

Chocolate Chip Cook...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Chocolate Chip Cookies

7 Posts
2 Users
0 Reactions
7,345 Views
somethingedible
Posts: 8
Topic starter
(@somethingedible)
Active Member
Joined: 8 months ago
[#6]

Hi! I'll bold my questions.

I took the cookies home from class and organized them from what I think is most structure to least "structure" (left to right). (By structure, I think I just mean bumpiness/ridginess and height). 

To me, the difference between C and B is very clear, and A also has some distinctiveness as a cookie because it has a ridgy-bumby top and is raised tall. But D and B seem really similar to me. 

1.) A has a higher proportion of egg white, while D and B contain less. Since the difference between B and D is barely noticeable, my takeaway is that the timing of egg addition—early versus late—had far less impact on gluten development than does the total amount of egg whites. Is my takeaway right in general, or is that just what happened in this case? Because when you look at C and A, you can totally tell they are bumpy, while when you compare D and B, it's harder to spot much of a difference between the two cookies. When I broke all the cookies in half, the interiors of the cookies didn't seem to tell me much, either (other than the fact that C and A are taller and D and B are shorter). 

2.) I want to recreate the experiment at home to try to make the differences in the conditions more clear to me. I'll remove both egg whites in the low-egg white condition (or have just one egg white) and add a bunch of egg whites in the other condition, so that I can see the difference in egg whites more obviously. But how can I mess with the "earliness" variable to make it more exaggeratedly clear what earliness does?

 

 

 


Topic Tags
6 Replies
somethingedible
Posts: 8
Topic starter
(@somethingedible)
Active Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Reply
somethingedible
Posts: 8
Topic starter
(@somethingedible)
Active Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Reply
somethingedible
Posts: 8
Topic starter
(@somethingedible)
Active Member
Joined: 8 months ago

Or maybe the structure in the cookies isn't actually due to gluten, and is the result of something else? 


Reply
somethingedible
Posts: 8
Topic starter
(@somethingedible)
Active Member
Joined: 8 months ago

If I mix flour and water, how much time do I have (if any) to be able to reverse the process and separate them again? Like theoretically (but actually in practice), if I pour a cup of water into a cup of flour and don't touch it at all, I assume I can't evaporate the water to go back to having just flour. Does flour become irreversibly chemically changed upon touching water? 


Reply
Page 1 / 2
Share: